The Damage of “On-Off” Rules
Yes, It Matters More Than You Think
Pet Parenting
February 01, 2026
One of the biggest mistakes even loving, responsible dog owners make is inconsistency disguised as kindness.
Examples dogs know too well:
From a dog’s brain, this sounds like:
“Try everything. You never know what might work today.”This is how anxious behaviour starts.
This is how demand barking grows.
This is how dogs become pushy, confused, or shut down.
On-off rules teach dogs to test boundaries constantly — not because they’re naughty, but because they’re trying to understand the system.
What Dogs Actually Need From Humans (Spoiler: It’s Not Perfection)
Let’s clear something up for every first time dog parent reading this.
Dogs do not need:
Dogs do need:
Dogs want to know:
This is responsible dog ownership in real life — not the glossy version.
You can miss a walk. You can have a bad day. You can mess up a training moment.
What matters is that your dog knows: “The rules didn’t disappear because my human had feelings.”
That’s safety. That’s leadership. That’s love in dog language.
Sniff of approval.
One of the biggest mistakes even loving, responsible dog owners make is inconsistency disguised as kindness.
Examples dogs know too well:
Jumping is cute as a puppy, annoying as an adult- Begging works when guests are around
- Pulling is fine when you’re late, not fine otherwise
- Barking gets attention sometimes, ignored other times
From a dog’s brain, this sounds like:
“Try everything. You never know what might work today.”This is how anxious behaviour starts.
This is how demand barking grows.
This is how dogs become pushy, confused, or shut down.
On-off rules teach dogs to test boundaries constantly — not because they’re naughty, but because they’re trying to understand the system.
What Dogs Actually Need From Humans (Spoiler: It’s Not Perfection)
Let’s clear something up for every first time dog parent reading this.
Dogs do not need:
Constant entertainment- Non-stop attention
- New experiences every day
- Humans who never make mistakes
Dogs do need:
Predictable routines- Clear communication
- Fair boundaries
- Emotional steadiness
- Presence without pressure
Dogs want to know:
Who’s in charge (so they don’t have to be)- What behaviour works
- What behaviour doesn’t
- That tomorrow will look a lot like today
This is responsible dog ownership in real life — not the glossy version.
You can miss a walk. You can have a bad day. You can mess up a training moment.
What matters is that your dog knows: “The rules didn’t disappear because my human had feelings.”
That’s safety. That’s leadership. That’s love in dog language.
Sniff of approval.
.png)